5 Tips for Choosing a New Wig

Choosing a new wig can feel overwhelming. With so many options, it’s easy to worry about making the wrong choice. You might be asking yourself, Will my wig look natural? Will it feel comfortable? What if I pick the wrong one and waste my money?
At Daniel Alain, we’ve spent decades helping people find high-quality human hair wigs that look and feel amazing. We understand the challenges of choosing the right wig, especially if you’re new to wig-wearing or transitioning to a different style. Our expert team has guided thousands of customers through this process, ensuring they walk away with a wig that suits their lifestyle and gives them confidence.
In this article, we’ll share five essential tips to help you find the perfect wig. From understanding different wig types to choosing the right color and fit, we’ll break it all down in simple, easy-to-follow steps. By the end, you’ll feel more informed, confident, and ready to choose a wig that feels just right for you.
Tip #1: Decide on Human Hair or Synthetic Hair
When choosing a wig, one of the most important decisions you'll make is whether to go with human hair or synthetic hair. Each has its own benefits, and understanding the differences will help you pick the right one for your needs from the start.
Human hair wigs offer the most natural look and feel, last longer, and can be heat-styled just like bio hair. If you want the flexibility to curl, straighten, or even change the color over time, human hair is the way to go.
Synthetic wigs, on the other hand, are lower maintenance and more affordable. They hold their style, even in humidity, and don’t require daily styling. The trade-off is that they have a set look and typically don’t last as long as human hair wigs.
Trish, a longtime wig-wearer, uses both. She wears her human hair wig every day because it looks and feels just like her real hair. It gives her confidence, and no one has ever noticed it's a wig. But when she’s outside gardening or lounging by the pool, she reaches for her synthetic wig - one she doesn’t mind getting sweaty or covered in sunscreen. Since synthetic wigs don’t always have the most natural hairline or part, she’ll pop on a hat for extra coverage.
When deciding between human hair and synthetic, think about your lifestyle. Do you want ultimate realism and flexibility or convenience and ease? Some people, like Trish, find that having both gives them the best of both worlds.
Tip #2: Find the Right Cap Construction
The way a wig is constructed plays a huge role in how natural it looks, how comfortable it feels, and how versatile it is for styling. Two of the most common types of wig caps are hand-tied and machine-wefted, and understanding the differences between them will help you choose the best option for your needs.
Hand-Tied Wigs
A hand-tied wig is made by individually tying each hair strand onto a soft, breathable cap. This process takes time and skill, but the result is incredibly natural. Because every hair moves independently, the wig mimics the look of hair growing from the scalp. This means you can part the hair in any direction - whether you prefer a middle part, side part, or even a zigzag part.
Another major benefit of a hand-tied wig is its styling versatility. Since the cap has no visible seams or tracks, you can wear your wig in a ponytail, bun, or high up-do without worrying about exposing any wefts. This makes it a great choice if you like to switch up your hairstyles. Hand-tied wigs are also lightweight and extremely comfortable, making them ideal for all-day wear.
Machine-Wefted Wigs
A machine-wefted wig is constructed using rows of hair sewn onto strips, or "wefts," which are then attached to a wig cap. This method creates a durable and cost-effective wig, making it a popular option for those looking for an affordable and long-lasting piece.
However, one thing to keep in mind is that machine-wefted wigs have limitations when it comes to styling. The wefts create visible rows, which means certain hairstyles - like high ponytails or buns - may expose the stitching. If you plan to wear your wig mostly down or in low ponytails, this may not be a concern. But if you love styling your hair in up-dos, a hand-tied wig will give you much more freedom.
Tip #3: Choose a Wig with High-Quality Hair
When choosing a human hair wig, the quality of the hair itself makes all the difference in how natural it looks, how soft it feels, and how long it lasts. Not all human hair wigs are created equal, and understanding what goes into the hair collection and manufacturing process can help you make the right choice.
Where Does the Hair Come From? Ponytail Hair vs. Floor Hair
The best quality wigs are made from ponytail hair - hair that has been cut while still tied together, ensuring that all the strands remain aligned in the same direction. This is crucial because it keeps the cuticles intact and running in one direction, preventing tangling and matting.
Lower-quality wigs often use floor hair - loose hair that has been swept up from salon floors or collected from hairbrushes. Because the cuticles are misaligned, this type of hair is prone to tangling. To compensate, manufacturers often strip the cuticles away completely and coat the hair in layers of silicone to make it feel soft initially - but this coating washes away over time, leaving the hair dry, rough, and unmanageable.
What to Look for in a High-Quality Wig
If you want a wig that looks natural, feels soft over time, and holds up to daily wear, look for one made with:
100% ponytail hair, ensuring all cuticles are aligned
Minimal chemical processing, preserving the hair’s integrity
No heavy silicone coatings, so the softness lasts beyond the first few washes
Tip #4: Get Measured for the Perfect Fit
If you’ve never worn a wig before, you might assume that a one-size-fits-all wig will work just fine. Or maybe the thought of taking measurements - or speaking to a consultant - feels a little uncomfortable. Hair loss is personal, and it’s understandable to want to handle things on your own. But when it comes to wigs, fit is everything, and taking a few simple measurements can make all the difference in how natural and comfortable your wig feels.
A wig that’s too big may shift throughout the day, causing you to adjust it constantly or worry about it staying in place. A wig that’s too small can feel tight, cause discomfort, and put unnecessary pressure on your scalp. Neither option will look or feel right - and the last thing you want is to spend money on a wig only to find out it doesn’t fit properly.
Tip #5: Try a Wig Before You Buy
Imagine spending hundreds - or even thousands - on a wig, only to put it on and realize it doesn’t fit quite right. Maybe it’s too tight and feels uncomfortable after an hour, or it’s too loose and doesn’t stay in place. Perhaps the color isn’t quite what you expected, or the density feels different than you imagined. A wig is an investment, and the last thing you want is to feel stuck with one that doesn’t look or feel like you.
That’s why trying before you buy - or at least getting expert guidance before purchasing - is so important.
Visit a Wig Retailer for an In-Person Fitting
If possible, visiting a wig retailer or salon allows you to try on different styles, cap constructions, and sizes. This way, you can feel the weight of the wig, see how natural it looks in person, and make sure it’s comfortable. A professional consultant can help you find the best fit and style for your needs, ensuring you walk away with a wig that feels just right.
Take Advantage of Virtual Consultations
If you don’t have access to a wig retailer, a virtual consultation is the next best thing. Many brands (including Daniel Alain) offer personalized online consultations where a specialist can help you choose the right size, color, and style based on your needs. At Daniel Alain, we provide fit kits that allow you to try different cap sizes and see hair samples at home before making a final decision.
Check the Return Policy
Even if you’ve done your research, there’s always a chance that a wig may not be exactly what you expected. Before buying, check the return and exchange policy to make sure you have options if the wig isn’t the right fit.
Ready to Find a Wig That Feels Like You?
Choosing a wig can feel overwhelming at first. Maybe you’ve struggled with finding a wig that looks natural, or perhaps you’ve bought one in the past that didn’t fit quite right. It’s completely understandable to feel uncertain about where to start.
Now, you have a clear understanding of what to look for in a wig, what’s next?
Take a moment to think about what matters most to you in a wig. Do you want ultimate styling flexibility? A lightweight, comfortable fit? A piece that lasts for years? Once you’ve narrowed down your must-haves, consider booking a consultation with a wig specialist who can guide you toward the perfect fit.
Finding the right wig is about feeling like yourself again. For one of our customers, the right wig was truly life-changing - giving her the confidence to step out into the world without hesitation. Your perfect wig is out there, too, and when you find it, you’ll know.